An Unprecedented Age

Some of my friends tell me that we should study past dramatic events, such as the Russian revolution or the rise of Hitler, because the future will be just like the past. Some of them seem to think that history is only capable of doing something like six different things, and so if our current situation starts to resemble some past era in some way, then that tells you which of the six things it is, and it’s going to go just the same way again. I’m not convinced of that.

History is worth studying — we can learn some useful things from it — but actually I think there are a lot more than six possibilities. And in fact, I think the situation has changed quite a bit from any past eras, and we’re not going to get anything very close to what happened in the past. I don’t know what is coming, but here are several major things that make our present situation unprecedented:

  1. The ecosystem is dying, far faster than most people realize, from a variety of causes. One cause is global warming. Global warming has feedback loops — i.e., some of its consequences are also causes — and that causes exponential growth. There may also be abrupt rises in temperature, as we pass through certain tipping points. Unlike previous catastrophes such as wars, the destruction of the ecosystem actually imposes a time limit on humanity: We have to fix this soon, or we’re going extinct. (And although it would involve a whole additional topic that I don’t want to take up here, it’s my opinion that we cannot fix this problem under our current economic system.)
  2. We are not just in late-stage capitalism; by now it is late-late-stage capitalism. More extreme than anything the world has ever seen before. Employees are being replaced by robots, far faster than most people realize. ALL jobs are now endangered. Of course, that means some past phenomena such as economic depression will be repeated — there are ever fewer employed people with money in their pockets, able to buy the goods and services produced by those robots. But we won’t be getting out of the depression the same way we did in the past. Carry it to an extreme: the only people with incomes are the handful of people who own all the robots. The only way to actually reach that extreme is by killing everyone else, or by giving everyone else a guaranteed basic income. Maybe the system will break down or change before we reach that extreme, and then I don’t know what will happen. But at any rate the current trend in the current economic system can’t continue much longer.
  3. Unlike previous centuries, we are living in the shadow of Edward Bernays and Walter Lippmann. The battles we must fight are battles of ideas, understanding, awareness, far more than ever before; they are not just battles with guns. Wars after Bernays (e.g., the CIA’s overthrow of democracy in Guatemala in 1954) are qualitatively different from wars before Bernays (e.g., the Russian revolution and Hitler’s war).
  4. Unlike previous centuries, we are living with a recent memory of prosperity. The so-called “golden age of capitalism,” around 1945 to 1970, was the one time in history when a market economy seemed to be working favorably for a large portion of society. Now that we know what prosperity looks like, we have to try to figure out how to make it happen reliably. — Advocates of capitalism, such as Simon Kuznets, have convinced themselves that the “golden age” was the normal behavior of capitalism, and all the other behavior we’ve seen was just aberrations that could be fixed by adjustments. But Thomas Piketty has shown, with extensive data, that just the opposite is true: the “golden age” itself was the aberration, and the general trend of capitalism is toward greater inequality. Piketty advocates taxing the rich, not just on their greater incomes, but also on their greater wealth — but the rich won’t let that happen, as long as they are in control. When more people understand this, they will demand change of a different sort.
  5. The past is not completely forgotten. Perhaps we don’t study history as much as we ought to, but some of its major features cannot be forgotten. The History Channel on television has played unending videos of World War II, so much that some people refer to it as “The Hitler Channel.” And every time some authoritarian politician makes any headway at all, bloggers and pundits are all asking each other “is he just like Hitler? has fascism begun to rise again?” This awareness does not completely prevent the rise of A New Hitler, but it does prevent a new rise of The First Hitler. If we get a new Hitler, he will be coming to a world that is already aware what it is like to have a Hitler. That doesn’t completely prevent the experience, but at least it changes the experience. Likewise for the Russian Revolution, or any other major drama from the past.
  6. new man new womanInformation is growing and communication systems are improving, exponentially fast, because they too are a feedback system — i.e., consequences are also causes. Computers and the internet have been improving by leaps and bounds, doing things never imagined or expected, and we can expect that trend to continue. This may lead to the creation of a heaven on earth or a hell on earth, depending on who is in charge (hopefully, all of us) and what their philosophy is (hopefully, peace and love). The question of gun control will soon be obsolete and old-fashioned, because soon people will be able to make guns on 3d-printers in their basements; gun registration won’t be able to stop that. In fact, soon, every suicidal madman will have all the information he needs to build a germ warfare lab in his basement, and that can’t be stopped by some authoritarian bully with drones. The only thing that can make us safe is a change to a culture in which everyone cares about everyone else, no one is left behind, and thus there aren’t any suicidal madmen. I don’t know just what is going to happen, but I think computer scientist Mark Miller had it right when he said

“You know, things are going to be really different! . . . No, no, I mean really different!”

22 Nov 2016, version 2.06. If you think of an additional major unprecedented thing to add to my list, please let me know.